Law Firm Guide to Attorney Referral Fees

//Law Firm Guide to Attorney Referral Fees

Attorney-Referral-FeesThere is a lot of confusion about attorney referral fees. Some attorneys and law firms aren’t quite sure about what’s ethical and what’s allowable. This mini-guide to attorney referral fees will take a closer look at attorney referral fees and how lawyers can have attorney referral agreements and stay within the rules.

What Is an Attorney Referral Fee?

It is common for attorneys to refer business to other lawyers, and when this happens the referring attorney may receive a lawyer referral fee in return. How attorney lawyer referral fees are arranged can be complex but must always fall within the rules governing lawyers. Here are some examples of when there may be a referral agreement between attorneys:

Example 1: An experienced attorney decides to pass on taking on a case that really doesn’t require her high skill level. She decides to refer the case to a new attorney who has his own small law firm. If there is an attorney referral fee agreement between them, the attorney receiving the referral will need to pay a lawyer referral fee according to that agreement.
Example 2: A new attorney doesn’t have the capacity to take on a new case because she doesn’t have enough experience. She decides to refer the case to a more experienced law firm. If there is an attorney referral agreement between her and the law firm, the law firm will pay an attorney referral fee to the referring attorney.

These are just two examples of when an attorney may pay a lawyer referral fee. But it’s important to note that any referral fee agreement between attorneys must comply with the ethics rules governing attorneys and law firms.

What Lawyer Referral Fees Are Allowed/Disallowed?

There are some attorneys who completely shy away from lawyer referral fees because they don’t want to get in trouble. In many cases the inclination to avoid trouble is a good one especially if there is a lack of understanding about what is allowed and what isn’t. First let’s take a look at the rules regulating lawyer referral fees and attorney referral fee agreements.

The American Bar Association (ABA) Model Rules of Professional Conduct has clear rules about attorney referral fees. These rules have been adopted without much change in some states. Check with your state rules to be sure of the rules for your practice. Model Rule 5.4(a) states that an attorney is not allowed to share legal fees with anyone who isn’t an attorney. And Rule 7.2(b) says that a lawyer isn’t allowed to give anything of value to someone for recommending the lawyer’s services. However, when you go deeper into the Model Rules, Rule 1.5(e) talks about exceptions to this general rule.
Attorney referral fees are allowed under the following circumstances:

  1. The division is in proportion to the services performed by each lawyer or each lawyer assumes joint responsibility for the representation;
  2. The client agrees to the arrangement, including the share each lawyer will receive, and the agreement is confirmed in writing; and
  3. The total fee is reasonable.

It’s also important to note that the rules also state that an attorney can only refer a client to another “competent” attorney. In other words, if an attorney refers a client to an attorney who they know can’t handle the case or who doesn’t have sufficient skills or experience, they could be in violation of the rules.

The ABA Model Rules governing lawyer referral fees aims to ensure that attorneys aren’t incentivized to refer clients simply to receive fees without doing any of the work. For obvious reasons, referrals tainted by greed or negligence can harm people seeking legal help and ultimately harm the legal industry.

Each state has its own rules regarding lawyer referral fees. And while some state rules follow the ABA Model Rules very closely some have added their own requirements so take the time to investigate your state’s lawyer referral fee rules before you enter into an attorney referral agreement.

Here’s an example of a scenario where an attorney referral fee may be allowed:

A solo-practitioner is slammed with work so he decided to refer some of his cases to another small law firm. He agrees to handle certain aspects of the case while the other attorney files all the required paperwork. The client agrees to the arrangement and all associated fees. The attorney referral agreement is in writing.

When you enter into an attorney referral agreement, be sure that your attorney referral fee percentage is reasonable and that the agreement is in writing.

Best Practices for Attorney Referral Agreements

Since both lawyers in a referral agreement are jointly responsible the case, referring a case can be risky. Here are some best practices for entering into a referral agreement.

  • Make expectations clear. Attorney referral agreements should be crystal clear about what each attorney on the case is expected to do. If only one attorney will be physically handling the case, make sure that your agreement states this fact. Otherwise, spell out in detail the responsibility of each attorney. The last thing you want is a misunderstanding about responsibilities in the middle of a client case.
  • Spell out attorney referral fee percentage. This is one place where you don’t want to make any assumptions. What percentage of the fee will the referring attorney receive? Depending on where your practice is located, typical attorney referral fee percentage can be 30% or more. Or, attorney referral fee percentage can be less than 30%. You need to figure out what the typical attorney referral fee percentage is in your state and what is considered reasonable.
  • Refer to trusted attorneys. When the ABA Model Rules state that you must refer to a competent attorney, they are making your responsible for the behavior of any attorney you refer a case to. This means that if the attorney makes huge mistakes, you could be sued for malpractice. This is why it’s generally preferred to refer cases only to attorneys you know and trust. If you haven’t worked with them before, you need to check their reputation to be sure that they are competent enough to serve your client.
  • Pay your fees. If you are an attorney who has received referrals, don’t run out of the fee. If you fail to live up to your attorney referral fee agreement you won’t be trusted again. If you’re balking at paying a fee “just for a referral” consider it the price of doing business without having to do any of the legwork to find the client. Help yourself build trust in the legal industry by paying your lawyer referral fees promptly.

The next time you decide you want to create an attorney referral agreement with another lawyer, check the rules and get advice from other lawyers who’ve done it before. And with an intuitive legal practice management software like Smokeball, you can even keep track of your referral sources. To learn more, schedule a free demo today!

By |January 9th, 2019|

About the Author:

For years, Josh has helped lawyers become more organized, productive, and profitable. A trained litigator, Josh came to Smokeball from a large east-coast law firm where his practice focused on franchise, insurance, marine, and general litigation. His work with Smokeball, and his continued passion for what he does each day, is driven by a desire to help lawyers and their staff do better in every way. Knowing well the stress and strain put on today’s legal professional, he regularly focuses on improving work and life in the law. He has traveled the country working with and learning from lawyers and their staff. Josh speaks regularly to bar associations about successful law firm practices and other legal topics. Recent notable engagements have been with the Chicago Bar Association, the Illinois State Bar Association, and the Missouri Bar’s Solo and Small Firm Conference. In addition to his work at Smokeball, Josh serves on the Writing Resource Center staff at The John Marshall Law School. Besides legal technology, his research interests include judicial decision-making, jury decision-making and psychology, and legal writing. He has written and overseen research exploring causal effects of sex/gender on federal appellate court decision-making, and assisted with research for a forthcoming textbook on judicial decision-making. Additionally, Josh sits on the Board of Directors of Chicago-based Community Activism Law Alliance and on the Board of Directors of Chicago Fringe Opera Company. Josh holds his J.D., cum laude, from Washington University in St. Louis, where he served as a Senior Editor of the Wash. U. Law Review, held the prestigious Thompson Coburn Research Fellowship, served as Research Assistant to then-Vice-Dean (now Chancellor) Andrew D. Martin, and clerked at the U.S. District Court for the Eastern District of Missouri. He holds a B.A. in Political Science and a B.M. in Music Performance with Honors Scholar distinction from the University of Connecticut, making him a Huskies basketball fan through and through. Follow Josh’s activity on LinkedIn, and keep up with new articles on the Smokeball Blog.

Leave A Comment